Tuesday, October 14, 2008 6:39 AM EDT
By Chad Selweski, Macomb Daily Staff Writer
The race for Macomb County’s two congressional seats took a dramatic turn with the meltdown on Wall Street and the ensuing Capitol Hill bailout for financial firms.
In the 10th District, U.S. Rep. Candice Miller voted against the rescue package while her Democratic opponent has called that move “reckless.”
In the 12th District, incumbent Rep. Sander Levin supported the package while his Republican challenger calls the $700 billion measure a move toward socialist government.
On economic issues, both House races offer voters a dramatic choice. The incumbents are prohibitive favorites to win re-election but their opponents promise substantially different policies if elected on Nov. 4.
“The biggest problem with the bailout is that we’re talking about using taxpayer dollars to bail out companies that made poor decisions,” said Bert Copple, 30, of Warren, the first-time candidate taking on Levin. “If you own a shop in Roseville and things are going badly, the federal government is not going to show up at your going-out-of-business sale to keep you going.”
Levin, 76, a 26-year congressional veteran, said the rescue plan was crucial at a time when the credit-crunch is having far-reaching consequences that could destroy small businesses and eliminate jobs.
“It’s clear that there had to be some kind of government intervention,” said Levin, a Royal Oak Democrat who represents most of Macomb County. “That’s not the road to socialism. That’s the road to rescuing the capitalist system.”
On Copple’s Web site, his blog goes to unusual lengths in warning about a slippery slope that could lead to an economy dominated by nationalized companies and federal programs.
“It is at that point that those who ‘cling’ to their Bibles and guns will hopefully bring them out and use them instead of just clinging to them,” writes Copple, a minister and former pastor of Evangel Ministries International in Roseville. “We need to be active in attacking this spirit of socialism.”
Miller, a Harrison Township Republican, stays away from such inflammatory, conservative language. Though she railed against the “fear factor” used by President Bush and Treasury Secretary Henry Paulson in selling the bailout plan, Miller, 54, is resigned to the new realities in Washington.
“Now that it has passed, we’re going to try to make this work,” she said. “I will do everything I can to make sure we have adequate oversight and hopefully prevent this kind of thing from ever happening again.”
Robert Denison, 67, a retired union official from Shelby Township, said Miller pandered to the populist position by voting against the bipartisan bailout legislation twice.
“I didn’t like the bailout, but it was necessary,” he said. “If Congress didn’t vote for the bailout, it wouldn’t just be a recession we’d be looking at, we’d be in a depression — locked into a depression.”
In the 10th District, which stretches from northern Sterling Heights to the tip of the Thumb area, the election contest is a rematch of the 2006 race. Two years ago, Miller trounced Denison by landslide proportions. This time, Miller has declined to debate Denison and won’t even comment on his campaign statements.
In the 12th District, comprised of southern Macomb and Oakland counties, Levin hasn’t faced a strong re-election challenge in many years. Copple, acknowledging that the district is 66 percent Democratic, has pleaded with voters to “stop voting for political parties as if it is some kind of religion.”
On other economic issues, the $25 billion loans provided by Congress to help the auto industry retool for renewable energy vehicles have met with approval from all of the candidates except for Copple.
“It’s telling other industries that if you get in trouble, the federal government will bail you out. That’s what socialism is,” said Copple, a manager for a company that provides non-medical, in-home care for seniors.
Denison, a former UAW representative, played a role in 1979-80 lobbying for the Chrysler bailout package. He notes with some whimsy that those loans — so controversial at the time — amounted to $1.5 billion. The new loans, he said, “will change the structure of the auto industry.”
His opponent agrees that the auto industry carries a special place in the U.S. economy.
“It’s highly unlikely,” Miller said, “that you can make the case that Lehman Brothers helped create the middle class. However, the auto industry literally created the middle class.”
On tax cuts, the candidates take a cautious approach, acknowledging that the growing federal budget deficit and the massive debt that will fuel the Wall Street rescue could severely crimp fiscal conditions in Washington. They also express grave concerns that the cumulative federal debt could drag down the next two or three generations of American workers.
“With this rescue package, the next president is going to have a very challenging time in trying to determine which tax cuts we can afford,” said Miller, the former Michigan secretary of state. “It’s difficult for us to get our minds around some of these numbers.”
Levin, like Denison, tentatively backs the Barack Obama tax plan but the congressman also advocates dramatic changes in global institutions such as the World Bank and World Trade Organization.
On trade issues, all four candidates say that the Michigan manufacturing economy deserves “fair trade” policies, with demands that U.S. trade partners adhere to basic labor and environmental standards.
Miller broke ranks with her party to oppose the Central American Free Trade Agreement and a pact with Vietnam. Levin, a leading critic of Bush administration proposals to open up new agreements with countries such as South Korea, said his battles with the White House are based on policy, not politics.
“You … can’t stack the deck and then say, that’s just the way the system works,” he said. “It (his opposition to Bush) is nothing that’s reflexive, it’s reflective.”
His GOP challenger said that Levin has had his opportunities to make changes in Washington and has failed.
“He has served as the chair on the subcommittee for Social Security, and Social Security is still broken,” Copple said. “Sander Levin serves as the chair of the subcommittee on trade, and our nation’s trade deficit continues to increase.”
As for Denison, his primary critique of Miller is that she has distanced herself from GOP policies and from the president in particular after serving as Bush’s Michigan campaign co-chair in 2000 and 2004.
“She is the ultimate chameleon,” he said. “She just puts her finger to the wind.”